Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Silver Earring

  • Wonderful settings and characters complete with voice acting
  • Large amount of content with multiple murders and 100s of clues to be uncovered
  • Makes some unrealistic leaps in story an clues that can be difficult to grasp without walkthrough help

Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Silver Earring (or simply Sherlock Holmes: The Silver Earring in North America) is part of the Sherlock Holmes franchise and the second in this series of adventures (proceeded by The Mystery of the Mummy and followed The Awakened). In addition to the Windows version launched in 2004 a Europe only Wii version was released in 2011 but was never made available to the rest of the world.


Despite this The Silver Earring is actually the prequel to every game noted above which makes it an ideal place to start for those wanting to try this Sherlock Holmes video game franchise. Set two years before the proceeding game this puts players smack bang in the middle of 1897 with Holmes and Watson investigating the murder of Sir Melvyn Bromsby with a number of suspects including his daughter already identified that require interview along with a broader clue and crime scene investigation.

Exploration in Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Silver Earring is done primarily through a point and click mechanic with players directing both Holmes and Watsons around the game world to investigate points of interest or talk to characters. This is facilitated with the left mouse button with prompts on the screen that show intractable objects or key walking spots that position players near objects or NPCs.


In addition players can right click which will bring up the inventory menu and contains your secret tools such as magnifying glass, test tube, measuring tape and a trusty notebook to read over any conversations (the main parts anyway). Like similar investigative puzzle games you’ll use these inventory tools at the right place and time to gather a piece of information or evidence while slowly piecing them together to solve the crime.

Through this exploration and inquisitive side of gameplay players will discover clues in a generally logical fashion with one clue leading to another which will only be available after a certain conversation or other action. These clues are the vital pieces of information that the police missed and can also analysed by Holme’s portable laboratory to extract extra information to help capture that sense of a dynamic duo with their own strengths and purpose.


On the surface Sherlock Holmes: The Case of the Silver Earring is possibly the best in the Sherlock Holmes adventure collection and as the prequel is an ideal place to start despite being the second game developed. It is only slightly let down by a few unlinked clues that can make it difficult to progress without external walkthroughs and introduces some frustration.


  • A Sherlock Holmes murder mystery that forms part of a 3 story collection with The Mystery of the Mummy and The Awakened.
  • Explore the crime scene, interview witnesses and collect evidence as you explore the game world.
  • Use your investigative tools like the magnifying glass to extract maximum information from locations.
  • Experience the prequel to the series, set in 1897 as you solve a murder mystery.
  • Voice acting and high quality graphics brings the game world and character interactions to life.



Review Platform: PC

This review was first published on . Read our update policy to learn more.

Written by
Samuel Franklin
Samuel Franklin is the founder and lead editor of the Games Finder team and enjoys video games across all genres and platforms. He has worked in the gaming industry since 2008 amassing over 3 million views on YouTube and 10 million article views on HubPages.

Games Finder is a Steam Curator and featured in the aggregate review scores data of MobyGames and Neoseeker.
Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.